When Your Friends Are Still Dieting: Protecting Your Recovery This Thanksgiving and Beyond

You’re doing the work. You’re eating regular meals, taking rest days, and trying to make peace with a body that’s changing. Then the Friendsgiving group chat lights up. One friend says he’s skipping breakfast to “save up” for dinner. Another is organizing a Turkey Trot so everyone can “earn” their pie. Someone’s already talking about the cut he’s starting the Monday after. And you’re sitting there wondering how you’re going to get through the day.

And sure, your friends aren’t trying to hurt you. Most of them probably have no idea that the way they talk about food and bodies is landing on you so hard. But when you’re in recovery, being surrounded by diet culture can feel like trying to stay sober at an open bar. You can love your friends and still need to protect yourself from some of the conversations that come with them. For many gay men, Thanksgiving with friends is the main event, a chance to celebrate chosen family, so it’s worth going in with a plan to take care of yourself so that you can have a good time.

Why this hits so hard

For many gay men, it’s hard to avoid conversations about dieting and bodies. In a study comparing gay and straight men, Jankowski and colleagues (2014) found that gay men had more frequent conversations about appearance, both positive and negative, and those conversations helped explain why gay men in the study were more dissatisfied with their bodies. The study can’t tell us which comes first, since men who already feel bad about their bodies may also talk about them more. Still, it suggests that the everyday back-and-forth about bodies, the “you look great, have you lost weight?” and the “ugh, I need to get back in the gym,” may play a bigger role than we realize.

Friends have a particularly strong pull. In a study of mostly straight college men, Schaefer and colleagues (2020) found that pressure from peers was more strongly linked to internalizing a muscular ideal than pressure from family. Peer pressure was also indirectly linked to disordered eating: men who felt more pressure from peers tended to buy into the muscular ideal more, which was linked to comparing themselves to others more, which was in turn linked to more disordered eating.

What makes this so tricky is that diet talk rarely sounds like a problem. It sounds like discipline, health, and self-improvement. When a friend announces a new cut, everyone cheers. When you skip it, you might be the one who feels like something’s wrong. If you’ve ever felt like the odd one out for not joining in, that reaction makes complete sense. I’ve written more about how appearance pressure shows up in our community in my post on weight stigma in gay male spaces.

Your friends’ choices are theirs, and your recovery is yours

One of the most freeing things to remember is that you don’t have to change anyone’s relationship with food. Your friends get to make their own choices about their bodies, even ones you’d never make again yourself. Trying to convince them to quit dieting usually leads to defensiveness and can pull you right back into the very conversations you’re trying to avoid.

Your job is narrower and more doable: protecting the space you need to keep healing. That might mean asking for some changes, stepping out of certain conversations, or spending more time with some people and less with others. None of that requires you to win an argument about nutrition, and trust me - it’s not worth trying.

Get clear on what’s hard for you

Before you can ask for what you need, it helps to know exactly what’s getting under your skin. Diet culture shows up in a lot of forms, and not all of them will affect you the same way. Pay attention to which ones hit hardest:

  • Talk about macros, calories, or “clean” eating

  • Comments about your body, including compliments

  • Friends comparing their bodies to each other, or to you

  • Talk about “earning” food or “burning off” a meal

  • Before-and-after photos, progress pics, or fitness challenges in the group chat

  • Gym plans that come with pressure to join or keep up

You might find that some of these barely register while others stay with you for days. That’s useful information, because it tells you where to focus your energy.

Scripts for everyday food and body talk

You don’t need the perfect words, and you don’t need to explain your whole history to anyone. Here are some options, depending on the moment and the person.

When you want to change the subject without making it a thing

  • “Okay, enough gym talk. How was the trip?”

  • “Can we talk about literally anything else? Tell me about the guy you’re seeing.”

  • “I’m going to sit this topic out. What’s everyone doing this weekend?”

When you want to be a little more direct

  • “I’m trying to take a break from diet talk right now. Mind if we switch gears?”

  • “I’m working on my relationship with food, so these conversations are tough for me at the moment.”

With a close friend you trust

  • “I’ve been working on some stuff around food and my body, and I’m in a place where hearing about cuts and macros makes it harder. It would mean a lot if you didn’t bring that up around me for a while.”

  • “I’m not asking you to change what you’re doing. I just need it to not be part of our time together right now.”

When someone comments on your body

  • “I’m trying not to focus on my body these days, but thanks.”

  • “I’d rather not get into how I look. How are you doing?”

  • For a compliment about weight loss: “I appreciate that you’re trying to be nice, but comments about my weight aren’t helpful for me right now.”

When someone comments on your food

  • “I’m good, thanks.”

  • “I’m eating what feels right for me.”

  • If it keeps happening: “I know you don’t mean anything by it, but I need you to stop commenting on what I eat.”

You’ll probably feel awkward the first few times. That’s normal. Like anything else in recovery, it gets easier with practice!

Getting through Thanksgiving and Friendsgiving

Holiday meals with friends come with their own set of predictable comments. Knowing what you’re likely to hear, and having a response ready, can take a lot of the pressure off.

“I’m saving up for tonight.”
Skipping meals before a big dinner is so common it barely registers as diet talk, but for someone in recovery it can be a slippery slope. Restricting earlier in the day can make it easier to slide back into old patterns, or set you up to feel out of control at the meal itself. I’ve written more about that cycle in The Restrict-Binge Cycle. You don’t have to respond to anyone else, but make a plan for yourself: eat regular meals that day, just like any other day. If someone asks why you’re having lunch, you can say, “I enjoy dinner more when I’m not starving.”

“Who’s in for the Turkey Trot? Gotta earn that pie.”

  • “I’ll cheer you on from the couch.”

  • “I’ll meet you all after. Save me a spot.”

  • “I’m sitting this one out, but have fun.”

“I’m being so bad today” or “It’s my cheat day.”

  • “It’s Thanksgiving. It’s just food.”

  • Or simply let it pass and turn to the person next to you with a different question.

“I’m in such a food coma. I feel so fat.”

  • “No body talk today, please. Who’s up for a game?”

  • “Let’s go for a walk and catch up.” (Only if a walk sounds genuinely nice to you, not like a way to make up for the meal.)

“Is that all you’re having?” or “Going back for seconds?”

  • “I’m good, thanks.”

  • “I’m eating what feels right for me.”

“I’m starting my cut on Monday” or “New Year, new me.”
The post-holiday “reset” talk can start before the dishes are even done, and it often carries through to January.

  • “Good luck with it. I’m sitting out the diet stuff this year.”

  • “Let’s not plan January yet. I’m still enjoying the pie.”

A few things that can help before the day

  • Pick a person. Let one trusted friend know what you’re working on, so you have someone in the room who can help redirect a conversation or give you a knowing look.

  • Bring a dish you feel comfortable with. Having at least one food you know you’ll enjoy without stress can make the meal feel more manageable.

  • Plan a non-food anchor. Offer to bring a game, make a playlist, or help with setup so you have something to focus on besides the food.

  • Know your exit. Decide ahead of time that it’s okay to step outside, take a break, or leave early if you need to.

  • Plan your after. Text your therapist, a support person, or a friend afterward, or plan something low-key for the next morning so you’re not left alone with any spiraling thoughts.

If family gatherings are also part of your holiday, my post on recognizing disordered eating during the holidays has more ideas for getting through the season.

Setting boundaries that actually stick

A boundary is about what you will do, not about controlling what someone else does. You can’t make a friend stop talking about his cut, but you can decide what you’ll do if he keeps bringing it up. That shift matters, because it puts the boundary back in your hands.

Here are some boundaries you might try:

  • Mute the group chat during fitness challenges or when the conversation turns to diets. You can always check back in later.

  • Step away from the conversation. Go to the bathroom, refill your drink, or start a side conversation with someone else.

  • Suggest plans that aren’t built around food or fitness, like a movie, a museum, a hike without a step count, or a game night.

  • Order for yourself, by yourself. You don’t need to talk through your meal choice with the table.

  • Limit time with people who keep crossing the line. That doesn’t have to mean ending the friendship. It might just mean seeing them in groups rather than one on one, or for shorter stretches.

The hardest part of any boundary is following through. If you ask a friend not to comment on your food and he does it anyway, it’s okay to remind him, and it’s okay to leave if you need to. Holding a boundary consistently is what teaches people that you mean it.

When a friendship can’t hold your recovery

Some friendships are built almost entirely around the gym, dieting, or a shared focus on how you look. When you step back from those things, you might find there isn’t much left to talk about. That can be really painful to realize.

It’s okay to let some friendships change shape. You might see certain friends less often, or only in certain settings. Some friendships may drift apart entirely. That’s a real loss, and it’s worth letting yourself grieve it rather than pretending it doesn’t matter. Outgrowing a friendship doesn’t mean either of you is a bad person; it just means your needs have changed. But sometimes, a friend will surprise you. When you’re honest about what you’re going through, you may find that someone you assumed wouldn’t get it actually steps up, or even admits they’ve been struggling too. Remember that nobody is completely immune from diet culture.

Finding people who support your recovery

Social support can make a real difference in recovery. In a small study of 19 women with eating disorders in Australia, Mitchison and colleagues (2016) found that about two-thirds of those whose symptoms had improved drew on support from family, friends, and other networks to start and maintain their recovery. Some described building new, healthier friendships and leaving less supportive ones behind. Men’s experiences are still badly understudied, but in my work with men, I find that having allies in recovery is crucial for long-term success.

A few places to look:

  • Friends who already don’t center bodies. Think about who in your life rarely talks about diets or workouts. Those people might be your best allies right now.

  • Communities built around something else. Book clubs, sports leagues focused on fun rather than physique or hookup culture, volunteer work, creative classes, or anything that gives you a reason to connect that has nothing to do with how you look.

  • Recovery and peer support groups. Being around other men who understand what you’re going through can be a huge relief.

  • A therapist who gets it. Working with someone who understands both eating disorders and gay men’s lives means you have at least one space where you never have to explain yourself.

Building new connections as an adult can feel daunting, especially for gay men. My post on whether gay men can just be friends explores how to build friendships that don’t revolve around attraction, appearance, or status.

In Closing

Protecting your recovery doesn’t make you difficult, dramatic, or a bad friend. It means you’re taking your physical and psychological well-being seriously, even when the people around you are heading in a different direction. Recovery can often feel like going against the grain. Please know that you’re allowed to prioritize your own needs. The right people will make room for that, and the ones who can’t may not be the right people for this season of your life.

If you’d like support navigating food, body image, and the relationships that come with them, I offer virtual therapy for gay men across MA, ME, NY, and FL. You don’t need to be in crisis to reach out, and you don’t need to have it all figured out first.

References

Jankowski, G. S., Diedrichs, P. C., & Halliwell, E. (2014). Can appearance conversations explain differences between gay and heterosexual men’s body dissatisfaction? Psychology of Men & Masculinity, 15(1), 68–77. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0031796

Mitchison, D., Dawson, L., Hand, L., Mond, J., & Hay, P. (2016). Quality of life as a vulnerability and recovery factor in eating disorders: A community-based study. BMC Psychiatry, 16, Article 328. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-016-1033-0

Schaefer, L. M., Rodgers, R. F., Thompson, J. K., & Griffiths, S. (2020). A test of the tripartite influence model of disordered eating among men. Body Image, 36, 172–179. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bodyim.2020.11.009


I'm Dr. Matt Richardson, a licensed psychologist and owner of Rough Waters Psychology, a virtual practice specializing in therapy for gay men navigating body image and eating concerns, and anxiety and self-worth. I work with men in Massachusetts, New York, Maine, and Florida.

If you're tired of the rules around food, the pressure to never miss a workout, or the constant focus on your body, book a free consultation with me and let’s talk about how we can turn things around.

Next
Next

Man Enough? How Masculinity Pressures Shape Gay Men’s Lives